Crystallography & Symmetry
patterns derived from their groups
Concept

Anomalous scattering — where it appears

Scattering at a wavelength near an absorption edge, where an atom's factor acquires an imaginary part and Friedel's law fails. That failure is what hands back the handedness of a structure, which a measurement of intensities alone cannot reach.

Named by 5 essays across one field — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

What each group extinguishes. The extinction conditions of 9 space groups, each derived by summing the structure factor over that group's own operations and reading the surviving rule off the result: P1 — nothing; P1̅ — nothing; P2 — nothing; Pm — nothing; P2/m — nothing; P222 — nothing; Pmm2 — nothing; P4 — nothing; P23 — nothing. 9 of the 9 extinguish nothing at all, and diffraction alone cannot distinguish those from each other.

Where the experiment runs out

Absences narrow the space group down and often not to one. Two groups can extinguish exactly the same reflections and scatter with exactly the same symmetry, and telling them apart needs something the diffraction pattern does not contain.

diffraction · Diffraction Friedel's law, as an equality rather than a resemblance. Each pair of bars is a reflection and its opposite for a structure of three atoms in no particular arrangement. They are the same height, and not approximately: with real scattering factors, negating the indices conjugates the structure factor, and conjugation does not change a modulus. The test behind this figure requires the largest difference over 40 pairs to be below 10⁻⁹ and it comes back exactly zero. This is why a diffraction pattern is centrosymmetric whatever the crystal is, and why the thirty-two classes collapse to eleven before a structure is even proposed.

The law that hides handedness

With real scattering factors, negating the indices conjugates the structure factor and leaves the intensity exactly alone — so every diffraction pattern is centrosymmetric whatever the crystal is. The escape is an imaginary component that the negation does not touch, and it is how the handedness of a molecule is measured.

diffraction · Friedel's law Two candidates, and the sign that chooses. The phase of reflection (2, 3), recovered from three measurements and no model. The circle is every complex number of the measured amplitude; the isomorphous difference fixes the cosine of the angle between the unknown phase and the heavy atom's, leaving the two candidates marked; the anomalous difference fixes the sine, which picks one. The recovered phase agrees with the true one to fifteen decimal places, and the true phase was never used in the calculation.

One experiment gives the cosine, the other gives the sine

Friedel's law holding exactly is what makes the phase unreachable. Its breaking is what hands it back: an isomorphous difference fixes the cosine of the phase and leaves two candidates, and the anomalous difference fixes the sine, which chooses.

diffraction · Friedel's law One number, and it is the fraction. Data simulated from crystals that are nought, a quarter, a half, three quarters and wholly inverted, each fitted for the single parameter. The fitted values sit on the diagonal to better than five parts in a hundred, which is what makes the parameter a measurement of composition rather than a test of a hypothesis: a crystal is allowed to be part one hand and part the other, and a value near a half is a real answer about the specimen rather than a failure of the determination.

How much of it is the other hand

A crystal of one enantiomer is a hypothesis, not an observation. What the diffraction actually measures is a fraction — how much of the specimen is the inverted structure — and the useful part of that measurement is the uncertainty on it.

diffraction · Friedel's law The same structure, mapped from intensities and from differences. Left, the ordinary Patterson map of the structure: 14762 interatomic vectors, a continuous field of overlapping peaks, and the two vectors between the anomalous scatterers — circled — nowhere among its strongest. Right, the map from squared Bijvoet differences over the same reflections: two peaks after the origin, and they are those two vectors. The difference map is 7381 times smaller a problem to read.

A map of the atoms that break the law

Feed a Patterson synthesis the differences between the two halves of each Friedel pair instead of the intensities, and the map that comes back holds the vectors between the anomalous scatterers and nothing else. Two atoms among a hundred and twenty-two: 14,762 vectors become two.

diffraction · The Patterson function

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

Structure factorBijvoet differenceFriedels lawAbsolute configurationCentrosymmetricChiralityFriedel lawLaue classPhase problemCentrosymmetryDiffraction symbolFlack parameter

All concepts