Depth

Ladders

A field says what an essay is about. A ladder says what else there is to say about it — the distinct arguments that stand against one idea, from the one that introduces it to the one that assumes all the others.
890 tilesthick ÷ thin = 1.6176golden ratio = 1.6180generated by substitution, never by placing tilesdepth 5

Penrose tilings

Two rhombi, a rule about how their edges may meet, and a tiling that covers the plane completely and never repeats. The five-fold symmetry a lattice forbids, obtained by giving up the lattice.

5 rungs · aperiodic
hexagonalequal lengths, angle 120°the arrows are the basis; the shaded region is one unit cell

The lattice underneath

Strip a pattern of everything but its repeats and a grid of points is left. That grid is not decoration — it is the object that decides which symmetries the pattern is permitted to have.

5 rungs · lattices
p1p2pmpgcmpmmpmgpggcmmp4p4mp4gp3p3m1p31mp6p6m17 groups, each generated and verified

The seventeen

Every way of repeating a pattern across a flat surface, exhibited rather than tabulated. The number is a theorem with a finite proof, and the proof is walkable in an afternoon.

5 rungs · classification
turn about a point, and nothing moves at that pointrotation

What a symmetry actually is

Not a property of a shape but a motion that leaves it alone. Once symmetry is a verb rather than an adjective, everything else in the subject follows — including why there can only ever be seventeen wallpapers.

5 rungs · operations
the crystal latticewhere it scatterslong in one is short in the otheraxis ratio 1.7

The reciprocal lattice

Nobody has seen a space group. Crystals are read from where they scatter, and where they scatter is a second lattice in which long has become short and short has become long.

4 rungs · diffraction
-2-10121-fold2.000integer — allowed2-fold-2.000integer — allowed3-fold-1.000integer — allowed4-fold0.000integer — allowed5-fold0.618not an integer6-fold1.000integer — allowed7-fold1.247not an integer8-fold1.414not an integer9-fold1.532not an integer10-fold1.618not an integer11-fold1.683not an integer12-fold1.732not an integerrotationtrace2 cos(2π/n) — a whole number only five timescomputed, not tabulated1, 2, 3, 4, 6

The crystallographic restriction

A repeating pattern may have rotations of order two, three, four or six, and nothing else whatever. The proof is one line of arithmetic, and everything finite in the subject descends from it.

4 rungs · restriction
a dot at (1/12, 1/12)8 symmetries per cella motif with no symmetry4 symmetries per cell57 of 121 dot positions give more symmetry than p4both generated with the 4 operations of p4the dot gains 4

The motif must be a comma

A dot is too symmetric to illustrate most wallpaper groups. Its orbit acquires mirrors nobody asked for, and the resulting figure is quietly of a different group from the one in its caption.

1 rung · classification
centred rectangular cellthe same points, primitive cell40 of 81 absent — h + k oddan absence is a fact about the description until it is shown to be one about the structureaxis ratio 1.55

Centring, and why cm is not pm

A centred cell has a lattice point in the middle and twice the area it needs, and crystallography prefers it anyway. The preference has a price, and the price is paid in reflections that vanish for reasons that have nothing to do with the crystal.

1 rung · lattices
p1hopp11gstepp1m1sidlep2spinning hopp2mgspinning sidlep11mjumpp2mmspinning jumpsolid line: a mirror · dashed: a glide · lens: a half-turn centreseven, and no eighth

Seven friezes

The same classification argument on a strip instead of a plane, where it is short enough to check by hand. Seven ways to repeat a motif along a line, with names like hop, step and sidle.

1 rung · classification
p4m55 of 324 samples17.0% of the cell8 operations, so one part in 8grid 18×18

The fundamental domain

The smallest piece of a pattern from which the group rebuilds the rest. Drawing one is easy and drawing one correctly is not, because a region with a gap or an overlap looks exactly like a region without.

1 rung · operations
grouppositions at which a dot gives a different group (of 121)p1121 / 121pm121 / 121pg121 / 121cm121 / 121p385 / 121p3m167 / 121pgg57 / 121p457 / 121pmg41 / 121p4g41 / 121pmm40 / 121p637 / 121p31m29 / 121cmm20 / 121p4m20 / 121p28 / 121p6m2 / 1214 groups fail at every position · p6m fails at 2each orbit's symmetry detected from the point set11×11 grid

The groups ornament actually uses

Seventeen exist and decoration does not use them evenly. Which are common is an empirical question that published surveys answer differently, and part of the reason is a hazard this site can measure exactly.

1 rung · classification
181 reflections10-fold symmetryforbidden to any latticeinteger combinations of ten star vectorsaperiodic

What Shechtman measured

A diffraction pattern with sharp spots and tenfold symmetry, in April 1982. Sharpness meant order and tenfold meant no lattice, and the two had been believed inseparable — so the interesting question is what the observation had to rule out before it could mean anything.

1 rung · aperiodic

All essays