Crystallography & Symmetry
patterns derived from their groups
Concept

Centrosymmetry — where it appears

The presence of an inversion centre, which sends every point to its opposite through one fixed point. A diffraction pattern has it whatever the crystal does, which is why the thirty-two classes collapse to eleven before a reflection is indexed.

Named by 7 essays across 2 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

Friedel's law, as an equality rather than a resemblance. Each pair of bars is a reflection and its opposite for a structure of three atoms in no particular arrangement. They are the same height, and not approximately: with real scattering factors, negating the indices conjugates the structure factor, and conjugation does not change a modulus. The test behind this figure requires the largest difference over 40 pairs to be below 10⁻⁹ and it comes back exactly zero. This is why a diffraction pattern is centrosymmetric whatever the crystal is, and why the thirty-two classes collapse to eleven before a structure is even proposed.

The law that hides handedness

With real scattering factors, negating the indices conjugates the structure factor and leaves the intensity exactly alone — so every diffraction pattern is centrosymmetric whatever the crystal is. The escape is an imaginary component that the negation does not touch, and it is how the handedness of a molecule is measured.

diffraction · Friedel's law Two structures on 8 sites with the same vectors. Two arrangements of 4 atoms on a ring of 8 positions. They are not the same arrangement — no rotation of the ring and no reflection carries one onto the other — and every interatomic vector occurs the same number of times in both. The bars below are the shared vector counts, which is the Patterson function of each: the tall one at the origin is the atom count and carries no information, and everything else is what a diffraction experiment measures. Their diffraction patterns are identical in every intensity, so no measurement of intensities, at any resolution, distinguishes them.

Two structures, one Patterson

Eight arrangements of four atoms on a ring of eight sites, and only seven distinct sets of interatomic vectors between them. Two of the arrangements are genuinely different and no measurement of intensities can tell them apart — at any resolution, for ever.

diffraction · Homometry Where a homometric pair comes from. A set that factors as a sumset gives its own partner. If every point of A is a sum b + c with b in B and c in C, and every sum arises once, then reversing C produces a different set with the same vectors — because reversing a factor and reversing its conjugate cancel in the product that the vector set is. Both factors must be asymmetric, which is the constraint that decides where the construction can be used: a two-point set is its own reflection up to a translation, so the smallest useful factorisation is three points by three points, and the smallest structure it builds has nine atoms.

Where the pairs come from

A structure whose atoms are the sums of two smaller sets has a partner: reverse one factor and the interatomic vectors do not notice. The construction is Patterson's own, it explains why homometry exists, and the smallest structure it can build has nine atoms for a reason worth following.

diffraction · Homometry pg scatters as pmm. The orbit of a motif under pg, and the set of all ordered differences between its points brought to a common origin. The vector set was handed to the detector with no indication of where it came from, and came back as pmm: 31 peaks from 6 atoms, on the same lattice.

Seventeen groups, seven vector sets

A map of interatomic vectors is more symmetric than the structure it came from, twice over: it always acquires a centre, and it loses every translation part. So a glide becomes a mirror, seventeen plane groups collapse onto seven — and the collapse is verified by handing the vectors to a detector that has never heard of Patterson.

diffraction · The Patterson function pmg: 80 of 80 restricted. The reflections of pmg inside a window of ±4, with the ones whose phase symmetry restricts to two values picked out. Every solid spot has a structure factor that must be real up to a fixed rotation — a sign, in effect — whatever the atoms turn out to be, and the pale ones have a phase symmetry says nothing about. The 4 palest spots carry two incompatible restrictions at once, which leaves them nothing to be but zero. Which spots these are was computed from the operations, before any structure existed.

The zones that behave as if there were a centre

The phase problem is usually stated as though symmetry had nothing to say about phases. It is true of most reflections and false of some, and which is decidable from the group alone: where an operation carries a reflection onto its own negative, the phase is confined to two values half a turn apart, computed from that operation's translation.

diffraction · Statistics Two populations, and neither of them empty. The reflections of a structure in which three quarters of the atoms are paired by a half-cell shift, sorted by the parity of h + k and each class scaled by its own mean. The two histograms have the same shape, which is the point: each class on its own is an ordinary acentric distribution. What differs is the scale — the odd class is a sixth of the even one on average — and no odd reflection is absent, so no extinction rule fires and nothing about the space group is affected.

A translation that is nearly there

Half a structure copied onto the other half by a half-cell shift, with nothing exact about it. No reflection vanishes, so no extinction rule fires — and the test for a centre of symmetry answers yes about a structure that has none.

diffraction · Statistics When a three-species superstructure's spots can go dark. Every structure of three species on the square lattice with three to eight sites in its primitive cell, using all three species, and every superlattice spot of each, sorted by whether the spot is dark for every choice of scattering contrasts, dark at exactly one ratio of the two contrasts, or never dark; with the number of distinct ratios and their degree over the rationals. At the primes 3, 5 and 7 no spot is dark for all contrasts and no dark ratio is rational: none at three sites, quadratic ones at five and cubic at seven. At four and six sites every dark ratio is rational, at eight some are and some are not, and at six and eight some spots are dark for every contrast.

Three species hide a spot at the golden ratio

With two species and a prime number of sites in the cell, no superlattice spot can ever be missing, because a sum of distinct roots of unity of prime order vanishes only when it is all of them. With three species the structure factor weighs two sums against each other with two scattering contrasts, and the argument changes shape without breaking. At a prime size no spot is dark for every contrast and none at a rational ratio of them, but a spot can be dark at one irrational ratio: at five sites, a power of the golden ratio. It happens only in structures with a centre of symmetry.

operations · Counting

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

Structure factorAutocorrelationEnumerationInteratomic vectorThe Patterson functionPhase problemSystematic absenceFriedels lawHomometryLaue classMeasurementSuperstructure

All concepts