Crystallography & Symmetry
patterns derived from their groups
Concept

Twinning — where it appears

Two or more orientations of one structure intergrown in a fixed relation, the relation being a symmetry the lattice has and the crystal does not. Which laws are available is a coset count; whether one is present is a measurement.

Named by 2 essays across 2 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

A diffraction pattern with tenfold symmetry. Sharp spots, arranged with a symmetry that no periodic crystal can have. When the ten-fold case was measured in 1982 the immediate reaction was that the sample must be a twinned crystal, because the alternative was that a theorem with a one-line proof had a case nobody had considered. The star of reciprocal vectors is a parameter here, so the eight- and twelve-fold patterns that were found afterwards come out of the same call.

What Shechtman measured

A diffraction pattern with sharp spots and tenfold symmetry, in April 1982. Sharpness meant order and tenfold meant no lattice, and the two had been believed inseparable — so the interesting question is what the observation had to rule out before it could mean anything.

aperiodic · Quasicrystals The twin fraction, recovered from a moment and nothing else (12 atoms). A structure of 12 atoms twinned at each of 6 fractions, with the second moment of its intensity distribution measured and the fraction solved back out of it. The recovery is within a few hundredths as far as thirty per cent — 4 rows here — and 4 of the 6 fractions get a number at all. Beyond thirty per cent the relation flattens: the derivative of 2α(1−α) vanishes at a half, the two roots meet, and a small error in the moment becomes a large one in the fraction. Where the sampled moment falls below 1.5 the quadratic has no real root and the estimate refuses rather than clamping, which is why a nearly perfect twin is the hard case in practice rather than the easy one.

A twin hides in the statistics

A twinned crystal scatters as two orientations at once and the detector cannot separate them. What arrives is a sum of two intensities — and adding two independent quantities narrows a distribution, which is a signature no model of the structure is needed to read.

diffraction · Statistics

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

Acentric distributionElectron diffractionIcosahedral symmetryIntensity statisticsMerohedral twinNormalised intensityQuasicrystalSecond momentShechtmaniteTwin fraction

All concepts