Crystallography & Symmetry
patterns derived from their groups
Generator

4mm: how many independent invariants there are at each degree

4mm: how many independent invariants there are at each degree
4mm: how many independent invariants there are at each degree. The number of independent polynomial invariants of the plane point group 4mm, one bar per degree from 0 to 8. The heights are the coefficients of the Molien series, computed from an integer recursion on the trace and determinant of each operation. A dot above a bar marks a degree where the same number has been computed a second way, by averaging every monomial of that degree over the group and taking the rank of the result — a computation sharing no code with the first. The two agree at every degree checked. Degrees where the bar is absent hold no invariant at all: for 4mm that is every odd degree below the first invariant, and it is a statement about which functions the group refuses to leave alone.

The number of independent polynomial invariants of the plane point group 4mm, one bar per degree from 0 to 8. The heights are the coefficients of the Molien series, computed from an integer recursion on the trace and determinant of each operation. A dot above a bar marks a degree where the same number has been computed a second way, by averaging every monomial of that degree over the group and taking the rank of the result — a computation sharing no code with the first. The two agree at every degree checked. Degrees where the bar is absent hold no invariant at all: for 4mm that is every odd degree below the first invariant, and it is a statement about which functions the group refuses to leave alone.

10 essays call invariant-ring. The drawing above is what it returns with no arguments at all; every call below passes it something, because a placement that passes nothing draws whichever member of the family the generator happens to default to rather than the one its essay argues about. Every one of this site's 393 essays names its parameters at the call site, which the standard pass of 2026-08-09 established and param-floor holds.

Where it is called

Changing this generator changes every one of these figures.

Dropping one invariant of 3m makes two orbits agree. Every lattice point within four cells of the origin, coloured by the values a proper subset of 3m's invariants takes on it — the 2 generators with the first one removed, over a window of 4 cells. With the full set, the 25 orbits of the group take 25 distinct sets of values, one each, so the invariants are a complete set of coordinates on the quotient. With one removed, the two circled points — in different orbits, so no operation of the group carries one to the other — take the same values and become indistinguishable. That is the whole content of the statement that a complete set of invariants separates orbits: the completeness is what is doing the work. Operations

An orbit is what the invariants cannot tell apart

Two points of the plane lie in the same orbit of a group exactly when every invariant polynomial takes the same value on both. One direction of that is a definition; the other is a theorem, and it is checked here by comparing every pair of points in a window both ways.

 The invariant degrees exist for every n; the lattice permits five of them. The reflection group with an n-fold rotation has an invariant ring generated in degrees 2 and n, for every n whatever — the dimensions on the right are counted by pairing monomials in complex coordinates, which needs no matrix and therefore no lattice. Five of these groups can be written in integer matrices, and those five are named in the middle column; the rest cannot, because a lattice has no five-fold or seven-fold rotation. The crystallographic restriction is usually a statement about traces of matrices. Here it is the statement that only five of these invariant rings belong to a crystal, and the two arguments have nothing in common but their answer. What a lattice forbids

The degrees that name the restriction

The reflection group with an n-fold rotation has invariants of degrees 2 and n — for every n, with no lattice anywhere in the argument. Which of those groups a crystal may have is then the only question left, and its answer is the crystallographic restriction arriving from a direction nobody points it from.

 4mm: how many independent invariants there are at each degree. The number of independent polynomial invariants of the plane point group 4mm, one bar per degree from 0 to 8. The heights are the coefficients of the Molien series, computed from an integer recursion on the trace and determinant of each operation. A dot above a bar marks a degree where the same number has been computed a second way, by averaging every monomial of that degree over the group and taking the rank of the result — a computation sharing no code with the first. The two agree at every degree checked. Degrees where the bar is absent hold no invariant at all: for 4mm that is every odd degree below the first invariant, and it is a statement about which functions the group refuses to leave alone. What symmetry decides

How many invariants of each degree

A group moves the plane about, and some polynomials do not notice. How many independent ones there are at each degree is a sequence of integers, computed here by a recursion on traces and again by averaging every monomial — two routes that share no code and agree everywhere.

 Six of the ten plane classes have a free invariant ring, and four do not. Every plane point group, with the degrees of the generators of its invariant ring, whether the ring is free, and the relation where it is not. The six generated by their own reflections — 1, m, 2mm, 4mm, 3m and 6mm — have two generators whose degrees multiply to the order of the group, which is Chevalley's theorem checked rather than quoted. The four without reflections — 2, 4, 3 and 6 — need three generators in two variables, so one polynomial relation ties them together, and the degree that relation appears at is printed at the right of its row. Nothing here is a lookup: the generators are found degree by degree as the invariants the earlier ones do not reach, and the relation is the kernel of the map back to polynomials. What symmetry decides

The groups whose invariants are free

Six of the ten plane classes have an invariant ring generated by two polynomials with no relation between them, and the six are exactly those generated by their own reflections. The degrees of those generators multiply to the order of the group, and their excess counts the reflections.

 4mm: which phase depends on where the order parameter points. The plane of a two-dimensional order parameter, with each sampled direction marked by the symmetry that survives when the parameter points that way. The directions along which some operation is preserved are drawn large with a spoke to the centre; the general directions, where nothing survives, are the small faint marks between them. One representation, several phases — and the symmetry does not say which of them a crystal takes. That is decided by terms in an energy, which no symmetry argument supplies: what symmetry supplies is the list a material must choose from. Into space

Which way the order parameter points

A two-component order parameter has a direction as well as a size, and the symmetry that survives depends on where it points. One representation therefore offers several low-symmetry phases — and symmetry, having produced the list, has nothing to say about which one a crystal takes.

 4: three generators in two variables, and the one relation between them. The invariant ring of 4 needs 3 generators, of degrees 2, 4, 4, and three functions of two variables cannot be algebraically independent. The relation between them is found rather than quoted: every monomial in the generators of the degree at which they can first be dependent is written out, the map back to polynomials in x and y is formed, and its kernel is the relation. It is then evaluated at points of the lattice, where all three generators take integer values and the combination comes to exactly zero. A group with a reflection has no such relation, which is the same statement as its ring being free. What symmetry decides

Three invariants and one relation

Four of the ten plane classes need three invariants where two variables can only support two, so exactly one polynomial identity ties them together. The identity is not recognised or recalled: it is the kernel of a linear map, computed and then checked at lattice points where every term is an integer.

 Which order parameters carry a cubic invariant, and therefore cannot grow from zero. Every order parameter of every plane class, with the number of independent cubic invariants it admits. The count is the degree-three coefficient of the Molien series of the representation's image — the same computation the invariant-ring figures make for a different reason — and Landau's condition is that it be zero. Where it is not, a free energy in that order parameter has a term of odd degree, which puts its minimum away from zero the moment the quadratic coefficient does anything at all, so the parameter jumps rather than growing. In the plane exactly two order parameters carry one, and both are the two-dimensional representation of a class with a threefold axis and no sixfold. What symmetry decides

The cubic term that forbids a continuous change

A crystal may lose a symmetry gradually only if the quantity measuring the loss admits no cubic invariant. Whether it does is the third coefficient of a Molien series — so a question about how a material changes is answered by counting polynomials.

 How many components a property may have, at each rank and in each class. One row per plane point group, one column per rank of a fully symmetric property tensor, with the number of independent components in each cell — counted by averaging the tensor over the group index by index, and equal at every entry to the Molien coefficient of that degree. A symmetric property of rank r is a form of degree r, so Neumann's principle and the invariant ring are the same arithmetic in two notations. The last column is the elastic tensor, which is not fully symmetric — symmetric within each pair of indices and under exchanging the pairs — and its counts are not in the table to its left. A property with its own symmetries needs its own average, and that is why the elastic constants are not read off a degree. What symmetry decides

The parts a property splits into

A symmetric property of rank r is a polynomial of degree r wearing indices, so the number of components a class permits it is a coefficient of an invariant ring's series. The elastic tensor is not a polynomial in disguise, and its counts are not in that table — which is the most useful thing about it.

 Which descents change the shape of the cell, and into how many shapes. Each descent the modes produced, with the number of independent strain components the parent class permits and the number the child permits. A transition is ferroelastic exactly when the second is larger — the child leaves alone a distortion the parent moves — and the difference is a spontaneous strain the crystal acquires without being pushed. The count of distinct shapes is the orbit of that strain under the parent, which can be smaller than the number of domains: two domains may differ in something a change of shape cannot show. Every count here is a rank of an averaged set of quadratic forms, computed twice — once by averaging, once from a character. Symmetry at work

The strain that arrives with the transition

A crystal that loses symmetry usually changes shape, and whether it does is a subtraction: how many strain components the child permits, minus how many the parent did. The difference is a distortion nobody applied, and it is what makes a domain visible in a microscope.

 12 of the thirty-two classes have a free invariant ring. Every crystal class with its order, the number of its operations that are reflections, whether its ring of invariant polynomials is free, and the degrees of the generators when it is. A reflection here is an operation of determinant minus one whose fixed set is a plane; an inversion centre has determinant minus one and fixes only the origin and is not one. The classes with a free ring are exactly the classes generated by their reflections, which is Chevalley's theorem checked rather than quoted. What symmetry decides

Twelve of the thirty-two are free

A crystal class leaves some polynomials alone, and the ones it leaves alone form a ring. For twelve of the thirty-two classes that ring is generated by three polynomials with no relation between them, and for the other twenty it is not — and the twelve are exactly the classes generated by their mirror planes. The two verdicts are computed by routes sharing no code, and an inversion centre is not a mirror.

The whole library · All essays