Generator

The phase problem — the phase problem generator

The phase problem

The same structure rebuilt from its diffraction three ways: with the true amplitudes and phases, with the phases scrambled, and with the amplitudes discarded but the phases kept. The atoms survive the loss of the amplitudes and do not survive the loss of the phases, which is what an experiment throws away.

5 essays call phase-problem. The drawing above is what it returns with no arguments at all; every call below passes it something, because a placement that passes nothing draws whichever member of the family the generator happens to default to rather than the one its essay argues about. Every one of this site's 393 essays names its parameters at the call site, which the standard pass of 2026-08-09 established and param-floor holds.

Where it is called

Changing this generator changes every one of these figures.

$The phase problem. The same structure rebuilt from its diffraction three ways: with the true amplitudes and phases, with the phases scrambled, and with the amplitudes discarded but the phases kept. The atoms survive the loss of the amplitudes and do not survive the loss of the phases, which is what an experiment throws away.$ How it is known

The phase problem

A detector records how much light arrives and not when it arrives, so half of every diffraction measurement is thrown away before it is written down. The half that is lost turns out to be the half that carries the structure.

$A structure, and the vectors between its atoms. On the left, 4 atoms in a cell. On the right, every one of the 16 vectors between them, each drawn from a common origin: 13 distinct positions, with the 4-fold peak at the origin being each atom paired with itself. That right-hand picture is what a Patterson map shows, and it is the thing a diffraction experiment gives without phases. It has more peaks than the structure has atoms — n² against n — which is why interpreting one is hard, and why it is always symmetric about its centre.$ How it is known

The map that needs no phases

A diffraction experiment measures intensities and loses phases, so the electron density cannot be computed from it. One map can be: the transform of the intensities, whose peaks are not atoms but the vectors between them — every ordered pair, brought to a common origin.

Three atoms, four resolutions. A one-dimensional Fourier synthesis of the same three atoms, cut at four different resolutions. Nothing is approximate except the edge: every amplitude and every phase used is exact, and the only information withheld is the reflections outside the sphere. The peaks broaden as the cut-off comes in, and beside every peak sits a negative ripple that the coarsest map cannot distinguish from a real absence of density. Both effects are the transform of the sphere rather than anything about the structure.

How it is known

As sharp as the sphere is wide

A map made from a truncated sum is not a blurred picture of the structure. It is the structure convolved with the transform of the sphere — so peaks acquire a width proportional to the resolution, and a negative ripple of twenty-two per cent that no improvement in the data ever reduces.

$Two structures on 8 sites with the same vectors. Two arrangements of 4 atoms on a ring of 8 positions. They are not the same arrangement — no rotation of the ring and no reflection carries one onto the other — and every interatomic vector occurs the same number of times in both. The bars below are the shared vector counts, which is the Patterson function of each: the tall one at the origin is the atom count and carries no information, and everything else is what a diffraction experiment measures. Their diffraction patterns are identical in every intensity, so no measurement of intensities, at any resolution, distinguishes them.$ How it is known

Two structures, one Patterson

Eight arrangements of four atoms on a ring of eight sites, and only seven distinct sets of interatomic vectors between them. Two of the arrangements are genuinely different and no measurement of intensities can tell them apart — at any resolution, for ever.

⟨cos Φ⟩ against κ, 379 triplets. The mean cosine of the triplet, binned by the concentration κ = 2|E₁E₂E₃|/√N, for the 379 triplets of a structure of 24 atoms whose reflections all exceed |E| = 1.2. The curve is Cochran's I₁(κ)/I₀(κ), computed from the distribution and not fitted to anything; the points are measured, with the number of triplets in each bin printed above. They agree to 0.1 root-mean-square. The measured points sit slightly above the curve throughout, which is the finite structure showing: Cochran's derivation assumes atoms placed at random and there are only 24 of them.

How it is known

Three phases that do not move when the origin does

A phase is a property of the description, not of the crystal: shift the origin and every one of them changes. A sum of three phases whose indices add to zero does not change, because the shifts cancel. That sum is the smallest thing about a structure that a diffraction experiment could in principle know, and it is not distributed at random.

The whole library · All essays