Crystallography & Symmetry
patterns derived from their groups
Series

Accidental symmetry — the series

5 essays on one idea, from the one that introduces it to the one that assumes the rest.
  1. Why p4 cannot be drawn with dots. The same group applied to a single dot and to a motif with no symmetry of its own. The dot's orbit turns out to have more symmetries than the group it was made with, so a figure drawn that way illustrates a different group from the one in its caption.

    The motif must be a comma

    A dot is too symmetric to illustrate most wallpaper groups. Its orbit acquires mirrors nobody asked for, and the resulting figure is quietly of a different group from the one in its caption.

    part 1 · classification
  2. What p3 scatters, and what the scattering shows. The structure on the left has point group 3, of order 3. The intensities it scatters, on the right, have point group 6, of order 6 — more symmetric than the thing that produced them. Reversing the sign of both indices conjugates every term in the sum and leaves the modulus alone, so a diffraction pattern always acquires a centre of symmetry, and in the plane a centre is a half turn. Both numbers are measured: the left from the operations, the right by testing each candidate against the computed intensities.

    The symmetry diffraction adds

    A diffraction pattern is always more symmetric than the crystal that made it. The extra symmetry is not a mistake in the experiment and no care removes it — it is a property of what a detector records, and it collapses the seventeen groups onto six.

    part 2 · diffraction
  3. p4m, displaced and then measured. Every atom of a p4m pattern moved by up to 1.2 per cent of a cell edge, and the resulting positions examined at 26 tolerances. At zero tolerance only the identity survives, so the structure has no exact symmetry whatever. Between 0.021 and 0.094 the count sits at 8, which is the group that was displaced. Above that it climbs to 15, accepting operations no version of this pattern has. The climb is not even steady: at 4 of the 25 steps the count falls as the tolerance is loosened, because operations accepted separately at one threshold merge into one at the next. The correct answer is a step on a staircase and nothing in the coordinates says which step.

    Near-symmetry, and the tolerance that is not here

    Symmetry decided by integer arithmetic never needs a threshold. Measured coordinates do not arrive that way, and the moment a tolerance is introduced the answer stops being a fact about the structure and becomes a fact about the threshold.

    part 3 · diffraction
  4. Every group a symmetric motif can lift a plane group to. The seventeen plane groups arranged by lattice, with an arrow from each group to every group a motif of higher symmetry, placed at some position, turns it into, on the generic lattice of the first. Dashed arrows mark the lifts that also halve the cell, two of which return the same type on the smaller cell. p1 lifts only to p2, the rectangular groups to pmm, pmg and cmm, the square ones to p4g and p4m, and p3 to four different groups. Three groups, outlined, cannot be lifted at all without a special metric: p2, pmm and p6m.

    Where a symmetric motif lifts the group

    A motif with more symmetry than its site asks for can raise the group of the whole pattern — or not, and which one is decided by the site, not the motif. The criterion is one line: a symmetry of the motif survives into the pattern exactly when it normalises the group. Run over every Wyckoff position of the seventeen, it finds twenty-nine of seventy-two where a motif can lift the group, general positions only in the four groups with a direction to slide along, two sites where the same motif gives different groups depending on how it is turned, and seven lifts between groups that halve the cell.

    part 4 · classification
  5. Two positions in three can be lifted, and more than one in three can lose their cell. All 1694 Wyckoff positions of the 219 affine types by crystal system. On 1132 a motif with more symmetry than its site can raise the group of the crystal, and on 606 of those, across 126 types, some such motif makes the true cell smaller than the group's.

    In space a motif can lift two positions in three

    A molecule with more symmetry than its site can raise the group of the whole crystal, or not, and which one is decided by the site. In the plane twenty-nine positions of seventy-two allow it. In space it is 1,132 of 1,694, and 606 of them allow a lift that shrinks the cell, the case a structure solution meets as a warning. General positions can be lifted only in polar groups, as predicted, but eleven polar groups refuse: a mirror turns their screws over.

    part 5 · classification

All series