Crystallography & Symmetry
patterns derived from their groups
Series

Modulation — the series

5 essays on one idea, from the one that introduces it to the one that assumes the rest.
  1. A chain modulated at q = 0.211. The lower row is the lattice: 34 sites, evenly spaced. The upper row is the structure: the same sites displaced by a wave of amplitude 0.12 of a spacing and wavevector 0.211, drawn through them. Because 0.211 is not a ratio of small whole numbers, no cell of any size holds the structure — the displacement pattern never repeats — and yet the atoms are nowhere near random: each one is exactly where a single sine wave says it should be. That is what an incommensurately modulated crystal is, and its diffraction pattern is sharp.

    The satellites that need a second integer

    A crystal whose atoms are displaced by a wave of the wrong wavelength has no unit cell at all, and diffracts to sharp spots anyway. Indexing them takes two integers per reflection instead of one — and the intensities of the extra spots are Bessel functions, which is a check the arithmetic can be made to pass.

    part 1 · aperiodic
  2. The chain as a cut through a periodic pattern. A periodic pattern in two dimensions: one atomic surface through each lattice point, drawn as the curve x = n + A·sin(2πy). The physical chain is the cut along the line y = qx with q = 0.211, and the atoms are where that line meets the curves — plotted along the bottom. Every cut meets every curve exactly once, so every cut gives a chain with the same 9 atoms and the same lattice, differently displaced. That is the difference from cut-and-project, where the atomic surfaces are intervals with ends and moving the cut adds and removes points: here the extra coordinate is a phase, and shifting it is a symmetry of the material rather than a different material.

    The extra dimension that makes it periodic

    A structure with no cell in three dimensions can be a slice through one that has a cell in four. The construction is cut-and-project with continuous atomic surfaces instead of intervals — and that single difference is what separates an incommensurate crystal from a quasicrystal.

    part 2 · aperiodic
  3. two chains, periods 1 and 1.62. Two interpenetrating chains of atoms with periods 1 and 1.62, whose ratio is irrational, so no length is a whole number of both. Each chain is displaced from its own lattice by a wave with the other's period — the short ticks show each atom's displacement from where an unmodulated chain would put it — which is what makes this one crystal rather than two side by side. Nothing here is a unit cell: any length chosen contains a whole number of one chain's atoms and a fractional number of the other's.

    Two lattices, one crystal, and no cell at all

    A modulated crystal has a lattice and a wave running through it. A composite has neither host nor guest: two interpenetrating substructures with periods that share no common multiple, each modulating the other. Every reflection needs an index from both, and the unit cell a diffractometer reports belongs to whichever half scattered harder.

    part 3 · aperiodic
  4. 21 superspace groups in (2+1) dimensions, from 31 names. The whole count, in the order it is built. Thirteen arithmetic classes of the plane; six of them admit an incommensurate wavevector; those six give ten sign assignments; each assignment contributes the plane cohomology times the internal cohomology, which is thirty-one names; and the names are merged by the changes of basis that are relabellings — a change of the plane basis, which moves the sign assignment and the internal cocycle with it, and the choice of q against −q. The last row is what the count would be if the two factors were quotiented separately, which over-counts because the merge is not independent of the internal part.

    Superspace groups in the plane

    A modulated crystal has no space group, and in a space of one more dimension it has one. Counting them in the plane is the seventeen's own extension arithmetic with a third coordinate on which the point group acts by a sign — and the sign has to be plus or minus exactly, which kills the three-fold, four-fold and six-fold classes before a single extension is counted.

    part 4 · aperiodic
  5. Every rational holds a window, and there is nothing in between. The ground state density of a chain of particles with a convex repulsion, against the chemical potential that sets how many of them there are. Every density with denominator up to 24 is a flat step of positive width — 177 of them — and the steps with the simplest fractions are the widest: a half takes 19 per cent of the whole range on its own. The risers between them are not smooth stretches; they are where the densities with larger denominators sit, and a finer computation fills them with more steps. What is left after every rational has taken its window is the irrational densities, which are the genuinely incommensurate ground states and have no width at all.

    Every fraction holds a window

    Three essays here name the devil's staircase and none computes one. A chain of particles with any convex repulsion has a ground state at every rational density holding an interval of chemical potential to itself — 709 of them computed, the widest taking 19% of the axis and the narrowest two parts in a million million — and the incommensurate densities are what is left over.

    part 5 · aperiodic

All series