Ladder

Seventeen — the ladder

5 distinct arguments against one idea, from the one that introduces it to the one that assumes the rest.
  1. p1p2pmpgcmpmmpmgpggcmmp4p4mp4gp3p3m1p31mp6p6m17 groups, each generated and verified

    The seventeen

    Every way of repeating a pattern across a flat surface, exhibited rather than tabulated. The number is a theorem with a finite proof, and the proof is walkable in an afternoon.

    rung 1 · classification
  2. p4msquare lattice · 8 operations per cellelements marked

    Reading Hermann–Mauguin

    p4g looks like a licence plate and is in fact a set of instructions. Half an hour with the rules turns the seventeen from a list to be memorised into a notation that can be read.

    rung 2 · classification
  3. p3m1hexagonal lattice · 6 operations per cellelements marked

    p3m1 and p31m

    Two groups with the same lattice, the same point group and the same number of operations, differing only in where the mirrors sit. The pair is the clearest evidence that position is as much a part of a symmetry as presence.

    rung 3 · classification
  4. 12346812p1p2pmpgcmpmmpmgpggcmmp4p4mp4gp3p3m1p31mp6p6m45 containments, 27 of them maximaloperations per cell on the leftdecided by set inclusion in a shared basishexagonal and square are not comparable

    The classification proof, one branch at a time

    Seventeen is a theorem, and the argument that establishes it is a finite case analysis that fits on a few pages. Working through it is the difference between knowing the number and knowing why there is no eighteenth.

    rung 4 · classification
  5. p6m37 of 324 samples11.4% of the cell12 operations, so one part in 12grid 18×18

    Orbifold notation, the shorter language

    Fold a pattern up along its own symmetries and what remains is a small surface with marked points. Its shape is a complete name for the group, and reading the name off costs an arithmetic sum that has to come to two.

    rung 5 · classification

All ladders