Crystallography & Symmetry
patterns derived from their groups
Concept

Quadratic form — where it appears

An expression a x² + b xy + c y² whose value at a lattice point is that vector's squared length. Every decision about a plane lattice on this site is made on the three integers rather than on the lattice's shape, which is what keeps the arithmetic exact.

Named by 14 essays across 2 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

The shells of the hexagonal lattice. Every point of the hexagonal lattice within a squared distance of 24, with a circle drawn at each length that occurs. The form is x² + xy + y², and the number of points on each circle is a coefficient of the lattice's theta series: 6 at 1, 0 at 2, 6 at 3, 6 at 4, 0 at 5, 0 at 6, 12 at 7, 0 at 8. The gaps matter as much as the counts — a circle with no points on it is a length the lattice does not have, and which lengths those are is a question in number theory rather than in geometry.

How many vectors of each length

Counting the lattice points at each distance from the origin turns out to be a question about divisors, and the answer explains something a crystallographer meets every day: why a cubic powder pattern has no line at seven.

lattices · Lengths In the plane, the lengths do name the lattice. Every reduced binary form with coefficients up to 20 — 1750 lattices — with its theta series computed to 120 terms. No two of them agree. That is Schiemann's theorem for binary forms, which says the theta series determines the lattice in two dimensions and in three, confirmed here as far as the search reaches rather than proved. The closest pair is worth the space: two lattices whose shortest vectors both have squared length twenty agree for 38 terms — because neither has any vector before then — and part at the next one.

The lengths do not name the lattice

Seventeen hundred plane lattices, every one with a theta series shared with no other — the lengths determine the lattice, and an exhaustive search says so. In sixteen dimensions two different lattices have identical counts at every distance, and the example is sixty years old.

lattices · Lengths The region every plane lattice lands in. The shape of a plane lattice is one complex number, τ, and every lattice can be brought by a change of basis into the region shaded here: the strip between 0 and a half, outside the unit circle. Its interior is the oblique lattices. Its left edge is the rectangular ones, its arc and its right edge the centred rectangular ones, and its two corners are the square lattice at i and the hexagonal lattice at ρ. Five kinds, and they are a region, three arcs and two points rather than five things of one sort. The region is unbounded upwards, where the cell gets longer and thinner without limit.

The space every lattice lives in

Five lattices in the plane is the number of *kinds*. The number of lattices is a continuum — and it has a shape: one two-dimensional region with two corners, three edges and an interior, where the five kinds turn out to be a region, three arcs and two points rather than five things of one sort.

lattices · Moduli The region, and its copies. Words in S and T up to length 4, each carrying the region somewhere else. The copies do not overlap and they do not leave gaps: the upper half-plane is tiled by them, one copy per change of basis. That is the whole content of the claim that reduction picks a canonical basis — every basis of every lattice is in exactly one copy, and reduction is the walk back to the shaded one.

Two moves reach every basis

A lattice has infinitely many bases and reduction picks one. Why it can is a fact about a group with two generators and two relations — and the fundamental region tiles the plane with its own copies, one per basis, which is what makes the walk home finite.

lattices · Moduli Sums of two squares, arriving as superstructures. Which indices admit a sublattice of the same shape as the square lattice, drawn as a bar per index whose height is how many there are. The pattern is not a pattern about lattices at all: an index works exactly when it is a sum of two squares, because a similar sublattice of the square lattice is multiplication by a Gaussian integer and its index is that integer's norm. The indices that work up to 30 are 1, 2, 4, 5, 8, 9, 10, 13, 16, 17, 18, 20, 25, 26, 29, and the same list is produced here a second time by factorising rather than by searching, with the two required to agree.

The sublattices that are the same shape

Thinning a lattice usually changes its shape. Sometimes it does not: the sublattice is the parent rotated and scaled, and a drawing of it alone would be a drawing of the parent. Which indices allow it turns out to be a question Fermat answered in 1640.

lattices · Sublattices A lattice placed in the region, and its distance to each special shape. The modular region, with the two special points marked — the square lattice at the top of the arc and the hexagonal one at its corner — and a third lattice placed by reducing its form. The distances are hyperbolic rather than Euclidean, and the choice is forced rather than aesthetic: a distance between lattice shapes has to be unchanged by every change of basis, and the hyperbolic metric is the one defined by being invariant under exactly that group. Writing the same lattice down on three other bases and measuring again gives the same two numbers to the last digit.

How far one lattice is from another

A crystal that is nearly hexagonal twins where an exactly hexagonal one would not, and 'nearly' does real work in that sentence. Giving it a number needs a distance that no change of basis can move — which forces the geometry to be hyperbolic rather than flat.

lattices · Moduli The whole space of plane lattices, and its corner. Every plane lattice appears exactly once in this picture. Scaling changes no density, so the leading coefficient is fixed at one; reduction then confines the other two to 0 ≤ b ≤ 1 ≤ c, and every lattice has exactly one reduced form. The curves are the levels of constant density, which are parabolas — a density d needs 4c − b² to equal (π/2d)². They crowd toward the corner b = c = 1, which is the hexagonal lattice at π/√12 ≈ 0.9069; the square lattice sits on the left edge at π/4 ≈ 0.7854. The picture is a search over a region rather than over a list, which is what makes the answer a decision: there is nowhere else for a lattice to be.

The densest lattice in the plane

Which arrangement of equal discs covers the most floor is a question about infinitely many lattices, and reduction turns it into a question about a two-parameter region with a corner. The answer is at the corner, and the argument finishes.

applied · Packing One net, six descriptions, four different answers about its symmetry. The honeycomb written against six bases of ℤ², all of them the same net. The detector tests each lattice type's holohedry in standard position, so a symmetry written against another basis is a matrix that is not in the list and is never tried — and the answer comes back as p6m, or an unnamed group of order four, or p2, or cmm, depending on how the voltages were typed. The metric column is the form the net's own edges make, inverted; the reduced column is that form after Lagrange–Gauss reduction, and it is the same in every row, which is what makes the last column a property of the net.

The symmetry a net was written with

A net has no coordinates, so its symmetry is whatever its best drawing has. This collection measured that by handing the drawing to a detector — and the detector tests a fixed list of matrices, so the answer depended on which pair of translations the voltages had been written against. The honeycomb came back as p6m, or p2, or cmm, or nothing, one net and four answers.

applied · Nets The alias accounts for every line and predicts more. The observed lines above, and below them the grid of a supercell that explains all of them. The full ticks are the observed lines, which the alias reproduces exactly; the faint ones are lines the alias predicts and nobody saw. That second set is the only thing that separates the two cells, and it is why an indexing criterion has to charge for unobserved lines rather than measure agreement.

Every alias is a supercell

A cell that explains every line of a powder pattern is not a near miss and not a coincidence: its reciprocal grid contains the true one, which means its own cell is a superlattice of the true cell. So the ambiguity of indexing is the arithmetic of superlattices, and it can be counted — two cells with one unknown, sixteen with two, sixty-two with three, all of them accounting for the same twenty lines exactly.

applied · Indexing Perfection is a rank, and most lattices do not reach it. For each lattice, the rank of the matrices vvᵀ built from its shortest vectors, against the dimension of the space of symmetric matrices those live in. Reaching it means the shortest vectors pin the form down completely: no deformation keeps every one of them at its length. Falling short means there is a direction left to move in, and the lattice is not a local maximum of density.

One perfect form in space

Which lattice packs spheres most densely is a question about a maximum over a continuum, and Voronoi turned it into a rank calculation and a sign check. A lattice is a local maximum exactly when its shortest vectors pin its shape down completely and its inverse can be written over them with positive coefficients. Searching every reduced integer form of minimum two finds one such lattice in the plane and one in space.

lattices · Packing How many similar sublattices the cubic lattice has at each scale. Every integer matrix satisfying MᵀM = α²I, counted up to the lattice's own point group by marking orbits rather than dividing. The even scales are drawn apart because they are the ones that give nothing new: a factor of two in the scale never produces a shape the smaller scale did not already have.

The shapes a lattice in space can thin to

In the plane, which indices admit a sublattice of the same shape is a question about which integers a quadratic form represents, and Fermat answered it. In space the question collapses: taking determinants shows the index is always a perfect cube, so there is nothing to represent. What is left is how many there are at each cube — and for a hexagonal lattice, whether there are any at all depends on one number.

lattices · Sublattices Four vectors summing to zero, and six numbers on the edges. A superbasis is the three basis vectors together with their negated sum, so the four sum to nothing and their pairwise products sit on the six edges of a tetrahedron. Selling's rule is: while any edge is positive, apply one transformation. The right panel is the same lattice reduced, with the vanishing parameters marked — and a vanishing parameter is a face the Voronoi cell does not have.

A reduction with one rule

Niggli's reduction is eight numbered conditions with sub-cases, applied in order until none applies. Selling's is a single rule on four vectors that sum to zero: while any of six numbers is positive, do one thing. It terminates sooner, its termination is a quantity that visibly falls, and when it stops the six numbers are the Voronoi cell — the pattern of which ones vanish gives Fedorov's five solids and nothing else.

lattices · Wigner–Seitz cells Three lattices no congruence can separate. The three reduced forms of discriminant minus twenty-three, with the integers each represents. The principal form represents one and the others do not; the others represent two and it does not. So they are genuinely different lattices — and they represent exactly the same residues modulo twenty-three, so they are in one genus and no congruence condition of any kind distinguishes them.

Lattices that agree at every prime

Counting the plane lattices with a given metric determinant is a class number. Above it sits a coarser count — the genus, which is what congruences can see — and for most small determinants the two agree. At discriminant minus twenty-three they part: three lattices representing exactly the same residues modulo everything, and different integers. No argument modulo any number can tell them apart, and they are not the same lattice.

lattices · Moduli The three minima of seven lattices. Every lattice scaled to covolume one, with the smallest radius at which a ball holds one, two and three independent lattice vectors. The last column is the shortest vector as a fraction of the longest any lattice of this volume can have — Hermite's constant — and only the face-centred cubic lattice reaches it. The fifth column is the product of the three, which is capped whatever the lattice.

A lattice cannot have all its vectors long

The three successive minima are the radii at which a ball first holds one, two and three independent lattice vectors. Nothing bounds any of them above on its own — a cell can be flattened without limit — but Minkowski's second theorem caps their product, so pushing one up forces another down. That is why every crystal has a shortest direction worth naming, and why a very anisotropic cell has a very short one.

lattices · Lattice

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

LatticeBasis reductionGram matrixChange of basisHolohedryIndexModuli spaceSublatticeTheta seriesUnimodular matrixBravais latticeClose packing

All concepts