Crystallography & Symmetry
patterns derived from their groups
Concept

Wavevector — where it appears

The label of a wave in a periodic medium, defined modulo the reciprocal lattice and therefore living on a torus. A crystal's operations act on it without the translations, which return instead as a phase.

Named by 8 essays across 4 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

p4m: 10 of 36 wavevectors have to be visited. The Brillouin zone of the square lattice with a grid of 36 wavevectors on it, of which 10 are drawn solid: one per star, which is everything a calculation over a p4m-symmetric operator has to visit. The share is 27.8 per cent against the 12.5 per cent that the order of the point group would give, and it is larger for a reason worth naming — the wavevectors on the boundary of the wedge have short stars, so they are over-counted by any argument that only divides by the group order. The identity that is checked is that the star sizes add to the whole grid.

The domain in reciprocal space

A fundamental domain is the piece of a pattern the group repeats, and this collection has drawn several. The same idea in reciprocal space is what makes a calculation over a crystal affordable — and its share of the zone is larger than one part in the group's order, for a reason worth measuring.

operations · Fundamental domain p4: (1/2, 0) has a star of 2. The first Brillouin zone of the square lattice, with the reciprocal lattice points at its corners and centre, and the whole star of the wavevector (1/2, 0) under p4. The star has 2 members and the little group — the operations that leave the wavevector where it is, modulo the reciprocal lattice — has order 2. The two multiply to the order of the point group, which is the orbit–stabiliser theorem and is checked rather than displayed. Each member is drawn at whichever of its equivalent copies lies nearest the origin, because that is where a reader expects a wavevector to be.

The star of a wavevector

A plane group acts on the plane, and this collection has spent two hundred essays watching it. It also acts on the reciprocal lattice, where the action is different in one decisive way: the translations move no wavevector at all, and come back instead as a phase.

space-groups · K symmetry p3m1 at (0, 0): the levels the little group requires, and the ones measured. The levels of the p3m1 model at (0, 0), with degenerate ones drawn thick. The little group there has order 6, and its characters predict levels of dimensions 1, 1, 2, 2. The measurement is 1, 2, 2, 1, and the account is "unitary". The values are numerical and the multiplicities are read at a stated gap; the prediction they are compared against is exact.

Where two levels must meet

At most wavevectors nothing of a crystal's symmetry survives, and its levels are as unconstrained as any operator's. At a handful of them a whole point group survives, and where that group has a two-dimensional representation, two levels are obliged to coincide — before anything about the material is known.

space-groups · K symmetry A wavevector of thirds, and the boxes that cannot see it. Which sizes of box can carry the wavevector at the corner of a hexagonal zone. The characters of the box's translation group are its wavevectors, and there are exactly N² of them — the fractions with denominator dividing N. A wavevector of thirds is therefore present in a box of three, six, nine or twelve cells and absent from one of two, four or five: not approximated badly, not resolved coarsely, absent. A mechanism or a level living there is invisible to such a calculation, and that is the practical content of a mechanism count depending on the cell it was looked for in.

Crystallography in a box

A calculation over a crystal is not performed on a crystal. It is performed on a finite block with its edges glued, and the block has a symmetry group of its own — finite, complete in one direction and missing something decisive in the other.

classification · Flat space The honeycomb's two levels meet at K, exactly. The two levels of the honeycomb net along a line from the centre of the zone to its corner. The off-diagonal entry of its two-by-two matrix is the sum of the phases of three bonds, and at the corner those phases are the three cube roots of unity, whose sum is zero — exactly, as an identity in the ring the phases live in rather than as a number that came out small. So the matrix there is the zero matrix and both levels are zero. It is the shortest exact statement of a crossing in this collection.

The crossing at the corner

The honeycomb's two levels meet at the corner of its zone, and the meeting is not approximate. Three phases sum to zero there — an identity between cube roots of unity — so the matrix is the zero matrix, and making the two sites differ opens a gap of exactly that difference.

space-groups · K symmetry p4m: freezing Γ3 leaves pmg. The same crystal three times. On the left, a pattern with the full symmetry of p4m. In the middle, the displacement each atom takes under the order parameter — the arrows are the mode, drawn in the first colour for one set of atoms and the second for the other where there are two. On the right, the atoms moved by a small multiple of those displacements. The group of the right-hand pattern is pmg, of index 4 in the parent, and it was found by the detector from the point set alone. The prediction — which operations carry the displacement field to itself — is made separately, from the mode and not from the points, and the two lists of operations are identical.

The cell a zone-boundary mode doubles

An order parameter that alternates from cell to cell keeps only half the translations, so the frozen structure has a cell twice as large and reflections that were never there before. The phases at such a wavevector are ±1, so the whole computation stays in exact integers.

space-groups · Landau The kagome net's level that does not move. Three levels of the kagome net across the zone, one of them flat. The reason is drawn beside it: a state that alternates in sign round one hexagon and vanishes everywhere else is an exact eigenvector of the adjacency operator at −2, because every site outside the hexagon that touches it touches exactly two of its vertices and those two carry opposite signs. The check is integer arithmetic in a supercell of 27 sites, with a residual of exactly zero. A state confined to one hexagon has no wavevector, and a level made of such states cannot depend on one — which is what a flat line across a zone means.

The level that does not move

Three levels cross the kagome net's zone and one of them is a horizontal line. The reason is a state that alternates in sign round a single hexagon and is exactly zero everywhere else — a solution with no wavevector in it at all, which is why no wavevector can move it.

applied · Nets the kagome net: 34 of 144 wavevectors carry a mechanism. The zone of the kagome net, with a mark at every wavevector whose rigidity matrix drops rank — which is to say at every wavevector that carries a motion of the bars. There are few of them and they are isolated, so enlarging the cell adds mechanisms slowly. The ranks at the half-integer wavevectors are exact; the others are computed with a stated tolerance, because the matrix there has genuinely complex entries.

A mechanism that is a wave

The framework essays found the kagome net's mechanism count growing with the cell it was looked for in, and recorded it as a finding without an explanation. Here is the explanation: the motions lie along lines in reciprocal space, and a larger cell samples a line at more places.

applied · Rigidity

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

Bloch stateLittle groupBrillouin zoneCrystal netDegeneracyIrreducible representationKagome netOrbit-stabiliserStar of kSupercellAntiphase boundaryBurnside lemma

All concepts