Crystallography & Symmetry
patterns derived from their groups
Concept

Setting — where it appears

A description of one group in a particular choice of axes, so that P2₁/c, P2₁/a and P2₁/n are three names for one space group. The literature contains all of them as though they were different, and deriving a symbol from a group's own operations is what shows they are not.

Named by 12 essays across 5 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

The wallpaper group p4m. A pattern with the symmetry of p4m, generated by applying the group's 8 operations to an asymmetric motif and repeating across the lattice. The symmetries of the result were then found independently and match the group exactly.

Reading Hermann–Mauguin

p4g looks like a licence plate and is in fact a set of instructions. Half an hour with the rules turns the seventeen from a list to be memorised into a notation that can be read.

classification · Seventeen Reading 4/mmm off its own directions. Each position of 4/m2/m2/m reports one symmetry direction of the tetragonal system: the highest-order axis lying along it, and whether a mirror is perpendicular to it. Nothing is looked up — every row is computed from the group's own matrices.

Reading a class off its own axes

A Hermann–Mauguin symbol is not a name that was assigned. It is a report on three directions, read in order, and the whole of it can be derived from the group's matrices — with one genuine convention and one exception, and the exception is orthorhombic.

point-groups · Crystal classes The space groups in class mm2 (P), counted. Every way of attaching translations to the generators of mm2 (P): 64 assignments close into a group of the right size, 16 survive moving the origin, and 10 survive relabelling the axes — which is the number the International Tables record for this class. the ten primitive orthorhombic groups with a polar axis.

Sixteen candidates, ten groups

One point group, one lattice, and every consistent way of attaching translations to it — enumerated in full. The count comes out at sixteen, and then at ten, and the step between the two numbers is a decision about what "the same group" means rather than an arithmetic fact.

space-groups · Space groups The crystal classes 3m, 3̅m, 6̅2m. 3m, 3̅m, 6̅2m: the orbit of a general direction under each group, giving 6, 12, 12 poles, with general positions and symmetry elements. Filled marks are poles above the plane of the page and open ones below it.

3m1 and 31m are one class

This site has an essay arguing that p3m1 and p31m are genuinely different groups. As point groups the same two objects are one class — and the two subgroups are each normal in the hexagonal holohedry, so nothing in the lattice relates them. What does is a rotation of thirty degrees.

point-groups · Crystal classes One lattice, two cells, and the absences the choice creates. The same set of points described on a centred rectangular cell and on its primitive rhombic cell, with what the centred description scatters. Half the reflections vanish, and they vanish because of how the cell was drawn rather than because of anything the crystal does.

Why the bigger cell wins

A centred cell has twice the area it needs and crystallography prefers it anyway. The preference is not conservatism — it buys operations that read as whole numbers along the axes, and the price is a set of reflections that vanish for reasons having nothing to do with the crystal.

lattices · Centring P2₁/c under every cell choice. One group, described in each of the 6 bases that keep its cell the shape its system requires, with the symbol derived from the operations each time. The distinct symbols are P2₁/c, P2₁/a, P2₁/n — 3 names for one group. Nothing about the crystal has changed: the basis changes all have determinant ±1, so the lattice is untouched, and the census of rotations, screws, mirrors and glides is identical in every row, since conjugation cannot turn one kind into another. What changes is which lattice vector a glide's translation is half of, and the glide letter names exactly that.

One group, three symbols

P2₁/c, P2₁/a and P2₁/n are the same space group written on three choices of axes, and the literature contains all three as though they were different. Deriving a symbol from a group's own operations shows why — and found an entry on this site that had been carried under another setting's name for two phases.

space-groups · Settings 3 lattices. 3 lattices: hexagonal P, with 24 symmetries; rhombohedral P, with 12 symmetries; hexagonal R, with 12 symmetries. The corner points are the conventional cell; the points in the second colour are the centring translations, drawn at every position inside the cell rather than one per face. The cell shapes are the picture's, chosen so no two systems look alike; only the angles a system is defined by mean anything.

A lattice described on somebody else's axes

R-centring a hexagonal cell does lower its symmetry, from twenty-four to twelve — and the lattice that results is the fourteenth, the rhombohedral one, which already appears on the list under its own axes. It is the only row in the enumeration where losing symmetry and being a duplicate are the same verdict.

lattices · The fourteen Bravais lattices Fddd has two published origins. The two conventions, computed from the operations. The International Tables place the origin at the point of highest site symmetry, and also at a centre of inversion, and for this group those are different points — so the group is printed twice, with every coordinate in the second table shifted by (-0.125, 0.125, -0.125) from the first. A structure published on one and read on the other has every atom in the wrong place by that vector, the refinement fails in a way that looks like bad data, and nothing in the symbol says which was used.

Two origins for one group

The International Tables place the origin at the point of highest site symmetry, and also at a centre of inversion. For twenty-four of the two hundred and thirty those are different points, so the group is printed twice with every coordinate shifted — and nothing in the symbol says which table a structure was written against.

space-groups · Settings Pnma has 6 names. The group Pnma with its three axes relabelled in each of the six possible ways. Every row is the same group, and each row is checked as it is drawn: the change of basis has determinant one, conjugating back gives the original operations exactly, and the census of screws, glides, mirrors and rotations is unchanged — and 6 different symbols come out. Each symbol is derived from the conjugated operations, not looked up, by the same routine that has to reproduce the symbol every group was entered under.

Six ways to name one group

Pnma is also Pmnb, Pbnm, Pcmn, Pmcn and Pnam. Nothing about the crystal changes between those six; what changes is which axis was called a. In an orthorhombic group the axes are inequivalent and unlabelled, and naming them is a choice made six ways.

space-groups · Settings P222: 16 descriptions of one structure. P222 has 4 operations in a cell. 8 origins leave every one of them exactly where it was, and 8 linear parts of the lattice's holohedry normalise the group, so its Euclidean normaliser has 64 elements per cell and the index is 16. That index is the number of coordinate lists that describe one and the same arrangement of atoms. Each was applied to a motif and the resulting point sets compared: the numbers differ and the sets are identical, which is the check that makes the count mean anything.

One crystal, and sixteen coordinate lists

Two structure reports can disagree in every number and describe the same arrangement of atoms, because a space group does not fix its own origin or its own axes. How many genuinely different lists there are is the index of the group in its Euclidean normaliser — a number, computable, and the thing a structural database has to divide out before it can say two entries are the same compound.

operations · Normalisers Four groups whose description count a metric can raise. Every plane group, the number of ways of writing one arrangement down on the lattice the group requires, and the number on the most symmetric lattice it may sit on. Eight groups already occupy the most symmetric lattice available to them and have nowhere to go. Four have a metric that raises the count, by two and in one case by six. The starred rows belong to groups whose normaliser has a free direction, where the quantity is a count of grid points rather than an index and cannot be compared.

The normaliser is not a function of the group

How many ways there are of writing one structure down is computed from the group and printed in a table beside its name. It is not a property of the group. Draw a p2 pattern on a hexagonal cell rather than an oblique one and the number goes from four to twenty-four, with nothing done to the group at all.

operations · Normalisers One change of setting, four rules. The four things a structure report contains and the rule each obeys under a change of setting with basis change P and origin shift p. The cell and the indices are multiplied by P; a coordinate is multiplied by its inverse, after the origin has been subtracted; and an operation is conjugated and then shifted by (W − I)p, a term the other three have no equivalent of. Applied to Pnma with the change below, the operations still close into 8, the orbit maps point for point, and every |F| is unchanged.

One matrix, four rules

Changing the setting of a structure is one matrix and one origin shift — and the cell, the coordinates, the indices and the operations each obey a different rule under it. Three of the four ways of getting it wrong still leave a closed group of the right order, so closure catches none of them.

space-groups · Settings

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

Hermann–Mauguin notationCentringChange of basisEquivalent originHolohedryInternational tablesNormaliserOrigin choiceConjugationCosetCrystal classGlide plane

All concepts